From the Roosevelt Island Twitterverse:

A video posted by ScottyP (@scottpiro) on

In August 2013 and February 2012 reported on a similar sighting.

A reader speculated the 2012 sighting was:

I think it’s the tail section of a Virginia-class submarine. Look at the diagonal fin on the bottom, then look at the back of the sub in this picture:
http://www.globalsecurity.org/…

(At first I thought it was the tail of a Seawolf, but they’re not building any more of those, apparently – the Virginia’s are smaller and cheaper)