Image From Architectural Community Alliance Of Roosevelt Island (ARCH RI)

As previously reported in May 2025, NYC Housing Preservation & Development (HPD) began efforts to demolish the Roosevelt Island Steam Plant building despite the opposition of some local residents. The opponents are concerned about potential health and safety risks resulting from demolishing the Steam Plant and question the need to demolish the building at all.

Instead of demolition, they argue the Steam Plant building can be adapted for other uses. A petition drive to stop the Steam Plant demolition and explore alternate uses for the site was organized by the Architectural Alliance Of Roosevelt Island (ARCH RI) and has 2363 signatures to date. Also, two Roosevelt Island residents have initiated a lawsuit to stop the planned demolition of the Steam Plant. (NY Times article here).

Here’s the current status of the Steam Plant demolition.

HPD Deputy Commissioner for Enforcement and Neighborhood Services AnneMarie Santiago reported during the October 21, 2026 Roosevelt Island Steam Plant Community Advisory Group (CAG) meeting that work will start on demolishing the Steam plant in mid November.

As shown in the HPD work schedule presented at the CAG meeting, smokestack demolition was scheduled to begin yesterday, November 12.

As of today, November 13, the demolition has not yet started.

Ms Santiago told the October 21 CAG meeting that demolition:

… will start in mid November and that will start at the west stack when the scaffolding is completed. The way that the work will be done … is that there will be hand demolition. So, someone will climb the scaffolding and knock the bricks into the chute of the stack and then the debris will be removed from the bottom entryway that they’ve built into the bottom of the stack. It will be wet work so as they’re demolishing the bricks the materials will be wet and knocked into the stack to minimize any dust….

During the November 2 Community Board 8 (CB 8) Roosevelt Island Committee meeting, ARCH RI Founder Kalin Kresnitchki asked RIOC President BJ Jones:

HPD said that the smoke stack demolition starts at any moment around November 12th. As of now, we don’t even know if there was environmental testing of the chimneys. Is there lead in the chimneys? Are there any heavy metals? And if someone did a structural evaluation of the condition of the chimneys hand on inspection and if these chimneys are in a condition that they are not going to collapse during the demolition process….

… if RIOC and BJ can personally promise to help us get this information. The question that I just asked, was there structural evaluation of the chimneys done? Are they tested for heavy metals and lead? We need to know this before the demolition start….

RIOC President BJ Jones replied:

… I can promise that we’ll continue with the Community Advisory Group and working with the elected officials at keeping HPD and DOB {NYC Department of Buildings} at the table to answer yours and and everyone’s questions about the demolition.

But these questions have not been answered and demolition is about to start.

On November 9, I asked HPD:

It was reported by HPD during the October 21 Roosevelt Island Steam Plant demolition Community Advisory Group meeting that demolition of the Steam Plant smokestacks is scheduled to begin in mid November. The 12th was the date mentioned in the meeting.

Is that still the case? Is demolition going to begin on November 12th? If not, when is demolition scheduled to begin? My understanding was that the community would be given 5 days notice before demolition begins? Who is to receive the notice?

I’m preparing a story on the steam plant demolition. Please let me know if there is any comment on the date demolition is scheduled to begin and any other statement on the matter.

View Of Steam Plant And Scaffolding On West Smokestack November 12, 2026

I have not received an answer yet from HPD. Will update when HPD responds.

What is RIOC’s role in the Steam Plant demolition? On November 5, I asked RIOC:

Paragraph 4 of the December 16, 2025 Future Redevelopment of Roosevelt Island Memo Of Understanding (attached) states that RIOC will lead the redevelopment of the Steam Plant and any proceeds of the Steam Plant site redevelopment retained by RIOC will be used to reimburse NYC for the lesser of

1- the actual costs of demolishing the Steam Plant or 

2 – $10.3 million.

Paragraph 4 states:

Does paragraph 4 accurately state the current terms under which the Steam Plant demolition will be paid for and the Lead Role that RIOC will take in the future redevelopment of the site?

If RIOC will be paying for the demolition of the Steam Plant site, why is RIOC deferring all decisions regarding the future use and planned demolition of the Steam Plant to NYC agencies?

RIOC Assistant Vice President Communications and Government Affairs Bryant Daniels answered these questions replying:

The Steam Plant is the City’s building, and the City is undertaking the demolition and currently paying for that work. Separately, the non-binding MOU outlines a potential framework for how the City, State and RIOC could work together on the future redevelopment of the site, including a possible reimbursement to the City for demolition costs from any redevelopment proceeds. However, the MOU does not establish a binding financial obligation for RIOC, nor does it commit RIOC to a specific redevelopment plan.

Any potential redevelopment is contingent on a number of factors, including the outcome of a comprehensive planning study and community engagement process, and the execution of a much longer extension of the Island’s Master Lease. While the MOU identifies RIOC as the prospective lead for future redevelopment, it does not give RIOC authority over the City’s decisions regarding the demolition of its building.

Two Roosevelt Island residents, Rachel Dowling and Tibor Krisko representing themselves, initiated a lawsuit using Artificial Intelligence to stop the planned demolition of the Steam Plant. According to the Article 78 Petition filed on July 3, 2026 (full listing of Court Documents in this case are here:

… 1. This is a special proceeding under CPLR Article 78 to annul a determination of the New York City Department of Buildings (“DOB”) that authorizes the demolition of the two masonry smokestacks of a 1939 industrial building at 5 East Main Street, Roosevelt Island, in the County of NewYork (the “Premises”), and to compel Respondents to conduct the environmental review and land use review required by law before any demolition of the Premises proceeds.

2. This proceeding challenges the determination of DOB embodied in Work Permit No. M01305740-S4-GC-CX, issued March 3, 2026, classified by DOB as an alteration but expressly authorizing the demolition of the two masonry smokestacks at the Premises, together with any final determination of Respondents first embodied in, incorporated into, implemented by, or made reviewable through that permit. Earlier acts described in this petition, including a July 2024 demolition order, are pleaded as background and as evidence of a single connected action improperly segmented from required environmental and land use review, and not as standalone determinations for which review is separately sought in this proceeding.

3. Petitioners appear pro se and bring this proceeding to preserve the limitations period….

Here’s the full Article 78 proceeding seeking:

  • to stop the demolition of the Steam Plant smokestacks and
  • an environmental and land use review before any demolition takes place.

According to an Arch RI August 14, 2026 press release:

NYC’s reply to the lawsuit is that an environmental review is not required prior to the demolition of the Steam Plant. According to Page 6 of the NYC lawsuit filing:

. ..Petitioners assert that the City was required to conduct an environmental review for the Department of Buildings’ issuance of a ministerial alteration permit. However, Petitioners overlook that this entire category of actions—building permits specifically and ministerial actions generally—is explicitly exempted from SEQRA requirements. Furthermore, Petitioners allege that
the Department of Buildings acted arbitrarily when it approved an alteration permit without inquiring into whether the building could be salvaged, and at what cost. Though the Petitioners insist that the agency was obligated to second-guess the applicant’s plans for its property, the Department of Buildings is a regulatory permitting agency, and is not empowered to make general policy decisions on Building Code compliant permit applications. Thus, the agency could not have denied the permit based on Petitioners’ desired criteria…

As of today, the Roosevelt Island Steam Plant demolition will begin soon but we don’t know the exact date nor have the questions asked about potential safety risks to the community be answered.

According to Ms Dowling:

I am concerned about dust, falling debris and any lead or other contaminants released when two masonry smokestacks approximately 210 and 240 feet tall are taken down next to my building … Efforts to contain the debris with tarps seem to be nonexistent in regard to the hauling trucks and the worksite itself.

and Mr Krisko:

Demolition cannot be undone. If the smokestacks are demolished before the Court reviews the permit, the harm to my family and my neighbors cannot be repaired, and our challenge may come too late to matter.

Watch this presentation made by Arch Ri co-founders Kalin Kresnitchki and Zora Boyadzhieva to the June 30 meeting of The Roosevelt Island Business Alliance describing efforts to oppose the demolition of the Roosevelt Island Steam Plant. They advocate for an adaptive reuse of the Steam Plant building instead of demolition, community involvement in the future of the site and transparency from NYC about the reason for demolishing the building.

More info at the RIOC Roosevelt Island Steam Plant demolition and ARCH RI web sites.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *